Know Your Lore: The Alliance

This week on KYL, we move away from the Fall of the Lich King (although in the months to come expect more Icecrown related KYL's) and out to the larger world and the major factions that contend across it. I thought we'd start with the Alliance this week for a number of reasons, the first and most important among them being that the Alliance would not exist without the Horde, while the Horde's existence owes itself to forces transcending the Alliance. Because of this, doing the Alliance first will leave open questions that the Horde section next week will help answer.
The Alliance as it stands at this moment in time is a far different entity than the one originally known as the Alliance of Lordaeron. That Alliance was one of seven human nations (Azeroth, Lordaeron, Stromgarde, Kul Tiras, Alterac, Dalaran and Gilneas) with the Dwarves of Ironforge, Gnomes of Gnomeregan and High Elves of Quel'Thalas. This Alliance was born directly out of the statecraft of King Terenas Menethil of Lordaeron and the military leadership of Anduin Lothar, the Lion of Azeroth and last living member of the original Arathi bloodline.
Each member of this alliance had various reasons for being in it and varying degrees of loyalty to it (the High Elves, for example, were only in the Alliance because as the last Arathi, Lothar could compel their loyalty due to ancient pacts and abandoned it as soon as it was possible for them to fulfill said pacts, while Gilneas retreated behind the Greymane Wall not long after the end of the Second War over differences of opinion with Lordaeron) and it certainly lacked in coherence compared to the Horde it was opposed to.
In fact, it's fair to say the Alliance of Lordaeron would never have existed if the Kingdom of Azeroth (Stormwind) hadn't fallen to the Horde in the First War. Lothar's desperate journey away from the ravaged capital of the southern human kingdom with the child king Varian Wrynn in his arms and his arrival in Lordaeron at Terenas' court is the stuff of legends now, but then it was a very near thing, a flight from bloodthirsty marauders who dogged their heels at every step and could easily have caught and killed them all. Even after Lothar made that dread trip north and roused the other human kingdoms, got Terenas on board, convinced the dwarves, gnomes and elves to join up (and even there, the Horde helped by doing things like recruiting the Trolls and attacking Quel'Thalas) the lack of unity in the Alliance of Lordaeron nearly cost it the Second War, Alterac being the most obvious example. If not for Gul'dan's treachery, in fact, the Horde most likely would have won the Second War and destroyed the Alliance of Lordaeron.
The aftermath of Gul'dan's decision to take the Stormreaver and Twilight's Hammer and go get eaten by demons at Sargeras' tomb was that the Alliance finally had the chance to push the Horde back, confronting Doomhammer and his forces at Blackrock Mountain, where Lothar met his death and Turalyon took up his shattered sword, defeating the Orcs and capturing or pushing them back through the Dark Portal. While the Alliance managed to exist long enough to mount the Alliance Expedition to Draenor following Ner'zhul and Teron Gorefiend's theft of the Book of Medivh, it disintegrated into squabbling and infighting not long after as Genn Greymane pulled out entirely over the question of letting the Orc prisoners from the Second War live in internment camps rather than exterminating them.
It's also necessary to mention the effect Daval Prestor had on the Alliance at this time. An unknown nobleman claiming relation to the deposed Perenolde dynasty of Alterac, he nearly managed to get himself married into the Lordaeron royal family and placed on the throne of Alterac at the same time. Luckily for Calia Menethil, for some reason Daval Prestor disappeared and she never had to marry him. Unfortunately for Alterac, this left the place to the mercies of the ogres and the Syndicate.
Ironically, the Alliance as a cohesive entity basically didn't exist during the Third War. Ner'zhul as the Lich King struck at Lordaeron alone, using Kel'Thuzad (a former archmage of Dalaran) to help corrupt Prince Arthas, who sailed to Northrend sans his father's approval after the atrocities at Stratholme, and returned, Frostmourne in hand, to slay his father and destroy his kingdom. The loss of Lordaeron and the creation of the modern Plaguelands spelled the end of the Alliance of Lordaeron as it stood, as did the destruction of Quel'Thalas and the pollution of the Sunwell to raise Kel'Thuzad as a Lich. The destruction of Dalaran followed hard upon. Jaina Proudmoore's flight to Kalimdor helped sever Kul Tiras from the remnant as well, as Admiral Daelin Proudmoore soon took the Navy to find her. This left a rebuilding Stormwind in no position to take action against the Burning Legion and the Scourge, and ragged bands of survivors throughout the Plaguelands under the command of men like Garithos acting on their own.
Meanwhile, the remnants of the Alliance under Jaina found themselves at first in conflict with, and then allied to, the Night Elves of Kalimdor. To this motley alliance were added the orcs, trolls and tauren under the young Horde Warchief Thrall, after subtle and not so subtle meddling by Medivh himself, no longer insane or possessed by Sargeras (and also no longer dead) - this assortment of mortals stood against the Burning Legion and its advance up the slopes of Mount Hyjal, but they fought at best a delaying action to give Malfurion Stormrage time to take action and make the ultimate sacrifice, destroying the World Tree Nordrassil and the night elves' immortality in the process.
To be honest, how we get from this moment to the current state of affairs between the Horde and Alliance is kind of vague. Part of it can be laid at Grom Hellscream's feet: while he and Thrall stood together against Mannoroth and earned Grom a hero's death, his previous actions in Kalimdor (drinking Mannoroth's blood in a tainted fountain and slaying Cenarius, the demigod patron of the druids and teacher of Malfurion himself) had earned the orcs a lasting enmity from the kaldorei. The Warsong Clan's further expansion north into night elf lands stoked the fires of hostility, and it's fair to say that without the actions of Grom and his Warsong Clan, the night elves would have had no compelling reason to join the new Alliance that rose after the Third War. Likewise, with the Scourge having destroyed Lordaeron by this point, human power was at its lowest ebb.
Gilneas remained sealed behind its wall, Dalaran was destroyed, Kul Tiras bereft of its ruler and most of its navy, Alterac a blighted land of thieves and ogres, and Stromgarde (already weakened by Thrall's campaign to free the orcs that destroyed Hammerfall and Durnholde Keep in occupied Alterac) found itself overrun with Syndicate from Alterac and ogres as well. This left only the former Kingdom of Azeroth (now calling itself Stormwind) as having any power and influence of the original seven, and Theramore Isle in Kalimdor populated by various refugees from the destroyed nations consumed by the Scourge and the Legion. We're still not aware of what, exactly moved the dwarves and gnomes to join the Alliance following the Third War (although we know the fall of Gnomeregan is what kept the gnomes out of the Third War) aside from general hostility from the Second towards orcs and trolls. It's possible one strong motivation to join was the existence of the Forsaken to their north, almost indistinguishable from the Scourge and slowly moving south through Silverpine Forest and the ruined lands of Alterac. Once the Forsaken joined the Horde, it only became more compelling to be part of an organization that could oppose them, one suspects.
At present the Alliance stands more united than ever. The admission of the shipwrecked draenei gave the night elves a closer ally in their attempts to reclaim Ashenvale and protect it from Legion demons and Horde incursions alike, as well as helping the Alliance make inroads with native draenei and lost ones in Outland. The return of Varian Wrynn spurred the Alliance into Northrend, where for the first time night elves, humans, gnomes and dwarves can all be seen fighting side by side against the Scourge and the Horde alike. Muradin Bronzebeard's return from seeming death has had a similar effect for Alliance unity, as has the more bellicose attitude of Garrosh Hellscream, Overlord of the Warsong Offensive and son of Grom, slayer of Cenarius. The very legacy of the Old Horde that serves to often unite the Horde seems often to unite the Alliance even more effectively.
Next week, we'll talk about the cost of all this: the deaths and worse of the Forsaken, the xenophobic betrayal of the Quel'dorei and their transformation into blood elves, the redemption of the orcs and their pacts with tauren and troll allies that helped create the New Horde from the ashes of the Old.
Filed under: Analysis / Opinion, Odds and ends, Lore, Factions, Know your Lore
Patch 5.4 patch notes
Virtual Realms feature revealed
The Proving Grounds are coming
The latest patch 5.4 news





Reader Comments (Page 5 of 6)
nirikun Dec 31st 2009 12:58AM
Well, there are actually some good reasons as to why the Night Elves demonstrate such loyalty to the Alliance. The Humans and the Orcs are still the respective glue that tie the Alliance and Horde together. They're the faces and leaders of it. The Night Elves had a good experience fighting with Humans against the Legion, whereas their interactions with the Orcs were, um, somewhat mixed to say the least. First impressions are always important.
Every other Alliance member has a beef with pretty much all the other Horde races except the Tauren. The Night Elves detest the Orcs, the Blood Elves, the Trolls, and the Forsaken for some pretty good reasons--at least in their minds. Lo and behold, the Alliance is the same. What better faction to align yourselves with?
Moreover, Night Elf society is poorly understood by most players, who view it through a cliche lens of nature-worshiping, anti-technological spiritualists. While there aren't any particular societal aspects that would unite the Night Elves with the Alliance as a whole, there certainly aren't any aspects that would divide them from it. As different as they might be, Night Elf and Alliance society are pretty compatible. None of their societies show any disrespect for nature, nor do they have some grand objection towards Druidism or Elune. There's nothing in Night Elf societal lore that says you can't cut down trees, use wood, study science, etc. They just are more interested in studying different aspects of the world, and until very recently Night Elves didn't really have much choice in what paths they took. Now that they've been forced to open up to the rest of the world, the Kal'dorei have actually done very well adjusting to it. You see plenty of young, eager Night Elves studying science and other arts that were simply unavailable to them for thousands of years.
As far as the Night Elves are concerned, they've really no social reasons not to join the Alliance, have some good political reasons to join it, and have a very long list of reasons to not join the Horde. Throw in some good personal interactions with its leaders and common folk and voila, you've got a steadfast Alliance member.
drakolord Dec 31st 2009 12:40AM
As for why the Dwarves and Gnomes would be part of the Alliance, people often forget that the Alliance from the 2nd War included Stormwind, technically. While the Lordaeron part of the Alliance fell, Ironforge, the Gnomes, and the Dwarves remained and never separated.
skinny Dec 31st 2009 1:23AM
yea....to all the people who are Garrosh bashing, yes right now he is a power crazzied dog who needs to be put down..yak yak yak, but if u all forgot BC take a trip back to Nagrand and visit him before going to Northrend he was nothing but a complainer plain and simple.....as soon as he meet up with thrall and learned what HIS father did that lite a fire under his @ss to do something to be remembered for other then "Garrosh, son of Grom, the slayer of the Nelf demigod"
and to the "EVIL" commenet we could all stay here for years yelling at each other about reason's why "the Alliance is evil" or "the Horde's evil" but it will never go anywhere the simple fact is that there both evil in some way because were always looking at its from the other factions perspective, and its not the entire faction is there are only some people who are really evil and the constant bickering about it isnt going to change people choices about what they think...i mean really in the Ally's eyes Thrall is a savage and evil but in the horde's eyes Varian is the evil one....and there some of u thinking well Arthas is the evil one but u are all forgeting that he was the one person trying to save his kingdom but instead let Vengence get ahold of him and consume him and thus turning him into the Lich King.
skinny Dec 31st 2009 1:29AM
and if were talking about Vengence consuming people for the wrong reason then that is also true about Maiev and her crazy quest to kill Illidain once and for all, i mean would u consider her being evil?? (she dose but anybody that has ran BT knows what happeneds at the end of it all)
Val Dec 31st 2009 1:44AM
Good read.
And I know another good reason why the Nelfs and dwarves stick with the Alliance.
Because of all the women.
PistolPeet Dec 31st 2009 4:06AM
I'd love to see this in time-line form. Above the line could be from Azeroth's perspective, and below the line could be which parts in WoW and the WC series we can play to see the key stages take place. It'd also be great if there was a map accompanying it with all these places marked on it.
Guildenstern Dec 31st 2009 9:22AM
"the xenophobic betrayal of the Quel'dorei"
Only on WoW Insider would the withdrawl of Quel'Thalas from the Alliance be seen as a 'betrayal'.
Give me a freaking break.
Matthew Rossi Dec 31st 2009 11:49AM
I was specifically referring to Garithos' xenophobic betrayal of the high elves and Prince Kael'Thas.
Al Jan 1st 2010 4:10PM
Poor Garithos. Kael and the Elves finally show up to 'help', after ignoring the Scourge outbreak until it trashed their city.
"Greetings peasant, I have lowered myself to join."
"Yeah great.. here's your mission."
"But that sounds tough!"
"Maybe you should have thought of that before letting zombies and demons butcher us. Now shut up and get over there."
"Peasant! I found others to do my work."
"... They look like demons!"
"Hadn't noticed."
"... I've had just about of you. Someone seize him."
tim Dec 31st 2009 9:56AM
One of the best lore articles I've read on this site. Keep up the good work.
KronosIII Dec 31st 2009 11:11AM
Der......the orcs were controlled by the legion to attack the alliance in the first place.
The trolls were basically killed by the alliance daily on their crusades. Hell most of the time the trolls kept to themselves and the alliance just come by to take land and do something about honor. If anything I think 4 or 3 of the original alliance kingdoms were troll land. And then the darkspear were going to be wiped out if they did not leave ZG.
The tauren basically did nothing, they had there own problems and are even more peaceful then gnomes.
The forsaken/high elves were basically screwed over by a racist dark knight. Which btw had no reasoning behind his evil and racism.
And the High elves n general are very cocky of themselves. And can't stand for a moment when their name is belittled. When most of them nent blood it was a timebomb waiting for a split with the alliance.
If I want to go further the Draenei are the reason for all of Azeroths suffering. Why? Do 2 giant demon lords named Kil'jaeden and Archimonde ring a bell?
So in general the light filled race that is supposed to be good is actually responsible for all the evil and suffering that has happened in Warcraft. Mostly because Velen was too much of a hippie and didn't stop them EVEN KNOWING IT WAS GOING TO CREATE DEATH AND SUFFERING IN THE UNIVERSE.
You can claim all you want even if (influenced/controlled) that the new founded Alliance is responsible for more evil then the Horde ever did.
Both sides still did plenty of wrong things though. But the Draenei in my opinion are the key factor of all the suffering in the universe.
Shizukera Dec 31st 2009 11:32AM
"If I want to go further the Draenei are the reason for all of Azeroths suffering. Why? Do 2 giant demon lords named Kil'jaeden and Archimonde ring a bell?"
Hey, why don't we just go all the way back and blame Sargeras, since he's the one who corrupted the eredar. Or just blame the Titans for not taking care of Sargeras when the butter started to slide off his biscuit. Those darn Titans!
/eyeroll
Poeryth Dec 31st 2009 11:47AM
Mostly because Velen was too much of a hippie and didn't stop them EVEN KNOWING IT WAS GOING TO CREATE DEATH AND SUFFERING IN THE UNIVERSE.
Yeah, because Velen could have totally stopped them on his own, considering there was two of them, and one of him, and they were both made even more powerful by the Burning Legion when Velen didn't have his own power enhanced in any way. THAT MAKES A WHOLE LOT OF SENSE. REALLY.
Both sides still did plenty of wrong things though. But the Draenei in my opinion are the key factor of all the suffering in the universe.
There are so many things wrong with your argument I don't EVEN
SaintStryfe Dec 31st 2009 2:14PM
Didn't the Draenei remnants join up with the Naaru after Sargaras made his offer? Your argument kind of falls apart - before the naaru, they had no specific holy power, just arcane.
KronosIII Dec 31st 2009 2:22PM
To Poeryth
He knew ahead of time of what would happen before they got powerful......
And Velen had many followers to help him take action against them. He only has himself to blame. And yes allot of Draenei joined with Sargeras.
I don't see what is wrong with my statement.
Al Jan 1st 2010 4:16PM
So even though the Night Elf army at the height of it's power, Super-Rhonin, a Saurfang, dragons and Cenarius only barely beat back the Legion with just Archimode present you think Velen and the loyal Draenei (some of whom betrayed him twice) should have tried rushing the Legion head-on with Archimode and Mal'Ganis there?
Tamarack Dec 31st 2009 12:05PM
Bring on the Pandarans! I want Pandaran monks! Can someone from the Horde go and spank one of their babies so they'll join us?
Seriously though... Good read. I really need to pick up the books as I love Lore but haven't followed it like I did when I played Everquest.
I do often wonder how Blizz will keep the lore going and how the player population would react if due to changing storylines that factions started to shift... for example sake... Tauren go Alliance and Nelfs go Horde... or if they were to start a new conflicting grouping... Horde players seem to be really deep with pride and if Blizz ever said... Forsaken and Belfs break off and join the Worgen and Dwarves in a new struggle against the Alliance and Horde... how that would play out. Crazy!
Personally even though the conflicts between Horde and Alliance have been there since day one I always get a sense of excitement when the two band together for the common good. AQ/The Wrathgate and it saddens me to hear that we may not put aside our differences when Deathwing threatens the world.
Or will we to a point? Blizz has made it clear they want the conflict between the two escalated but how will we overcome Deathwing and the chaos that seperated?
erines Dec 31st 2009 12:49PM
Garrosh is finite being a demon by nature (Kil) is an infinite being , Garrosh being born 'first' is simply impossible.
I always wondered why there is a little girl following one of the Cenarius around in that little Druid village in Blades Edge. She always asks 'where are her parents, and that she comes from get this : " a place called Englund".... did humans from Earth fall through a portal to Azeroth? If so should not Azeroth immigration Authorities send them back? Would not Earth be like Mexico to Azeroth? I think this aspect needs more exploration. Before Deathwing comes back and throws everything into chaos.
erines Dec 31st 2009 12:54PM
If I want to go further the Draenei are the reason for all of Azeroths suffering. Why? Do 2 giant demon lords named Kil'jaeden and Archimonde ring a bell?"- quoted from somebody...
Eredar and space goats : two different things. Space goats have no historical basis in Lore other than we are made to believe that they are somehow breakaways from the Legion. Frankly they were made up to satisfy even teams at release of The Burning Crusade. Blood Elves (who have a rich history in Lore) would have made the teams uneven. Yup read it and weep.
KronosIII Dec 31st 2009 2:29PM
http://www.wowwiki.com/Draenei
Time for you to read their lore I guess.....